Showing posts with label book clubs. Show all posts
Showing posts with label book clubs. Show all posts

Friday, February 13, 2026

Readers in the Rough Book Recommendations for 2026

L
January 2026, Kathy H., Rowena S., Tammy C., Letty,
 Linda E.,  Kathy T. We are missing our traveling friends. 
Photo by Letty's sister, Jonya. 

We LOVE TO READ

In 2025 we read the following 12 books and rated them according to our 'golf guide.' The rating system is based on the language of golf and quality of literature. 

A Par rating meets the expectation of the elements of fiction: a solid plot, strong and dynamic characters, setting that is defined, a theme we can discuss along with a point of view that lends itself to telling the story, and strength of genre. *It is important to note that individual perceptions matter. Although the reader may not find the main character likeable, if the main character develops and changes over the lifetime of the novel then s/he is  considered a dynamic character because of this change. 

A Par rating for memoir asks for a compelling story using truth, theme, voice, point of view being I, and an ongoing attempt to arrive at answers

At the end of each monthly discussion we talk through the rating briefly giving the novel/memoir a rating. To better explain our voting think of a scale of 1-5 with 5 being the best and you would recommend it to any type of reader, and a 1 being a bogey or would not recommend to others to read.  We then take the total and divide it by the number of readers to get the average. 

  • A Hole-in-One vote equals 5 points. 
  • Eagle vote equals 4 points. 
  • Birdie vote equals 3 points. 
  • Par vote equals 2 points.
  • Bogey is worth 1 point.
  • Double bogey is not recommended.
THREE books received the Hole-in-One rating (5 points)


West with Giraffes  is an emotional, rousing novel inspired by the incredible true story of two giraffes who made headlines and won the hearts of Depression-era America.

“Few true friends have I known and two were giraffes…”

Woodrow Wilson Nickel, age 105, feels his life ebbing away. But when he learns giraffes are going extinct, he finds himself recalling the unforgettable experience that he cannot take to his grave.

It’s 1938. The Great Depression lingers. Hitler is threatening Europe, and world-weary Americans long for wonder. They find it in two giraffes who miraculously survive a hurricane while crossing the Atlantic. What follows is a twelve-day road trip in a custom truck to deliver Southern California’s first giraffes to the San Diego Zoo. Behind the wheel is the young Dust Bowl rowdy Woodrow. Inspired by true events, the tale weaves real-life figures with fictional ones, including the world’s first female zoo director, a crusty old man with a past, a young female photographer with a secret, and assorted reprobates as spotty as the giraffes.

Part adventure, part historical saga, and part coming-of-age love story, West with Giraffes explores what it means to be changed by the grace of animals, the kindness of strangers, the passing of time, and a story told before it’s too late.


Two excellent books from completely different times and places. The Instrumentalist is placed in 1704 Venice with an eight-year-old orphan girl strives to become Venice's greatest violinist and composer. Her "sound-color synesthesia" abilities set her apart from the other girls and create a destiny for her. 
 
Becoming Madam Secretary introduces us to Frances Perkins at the turn of the last century who begins her destiny by working with children in the crowded tenements of Hell's Kitchen. Through her social scene in Greenwich Village she meets the people who will guide her to her future in the White House where she becomes FDR's Secretary of Labor (1933-1945) and what an amazing path she charted, as the primary architect behind the creation of Social Security. 


2025 became a banner year for those of us sharing opinions and personal reflections on the majority of the books we read.  Six of the books earned a 4 rating which is equal to shooting an "Eagle" in the game of golf.   
   
My personal favorite of the six books is LIFE IMPOSSIBLE by Matt Haig.  I knew all along it was realistic type fantasy, now called magical realism,  but in my heart I wanted it to be a true story. The author led me through an emotional attachment to the protagonist, 72 year-old Grace Winters. Grace takes a chance on life when she buys a one-way ticket to the Isle of Ibiza to live in a home given to her by a long lost acquaintance. Grace's experiences open the doors on both or past and future. I thought this quote best exemplified the story: “A wry and tender love-letter to the best of being human.” —Benedict Cumberbatch 

The next five books take us on journeys in time and setting.  HORSE by Geraldine Brooks is an historical novel of the legendary race horse, Lexington. 

JAMES is a novel that retells Mark Twain's Adventures of Huckleberry Finn from the perspective of the enslaved character, Jim, who is called James. This story swept me away from housework and meals. 

The Gown: A Novel of the Royal Wedding is another historical fiction that tells the story of the embroiderers who created Princess Elizabeth's wedding gown in 1947. This story is interwoven with a modern-day story about a women discovering her grandmother's connection to the dress.                                                                                              
 TELL ME EVERYTHING reconnects us with Olive Kitteridge and Lucy Barton. As only Strout can do, she brings each character to life through individual stories  that show how all of our lives are connected in one way or another. 

ISOLA is based on the true life of Marguerite de la Rocque, a wealthy noble woman who inherited a great wealth as a child, only to have it gambled and lost by her trusted uncle. To image this noble woman who could do nothing for herself abandoned on an island in Canada. It is a fight for survival with surprising twists. It reminded me of the old black and white movies I watched as child when I wanted to scream at the heroine and tell her who to look out for. 
This year all of our books broke PAR. That is quite an accomplishment whether in literature or golf. The three books receiving the rating of "Birdie" one stroke better than par come from different genres. 


Hanks take us through the process of making a motion picture, a difficult task it is to produce and direct but also to write about clearly. I had to reread passages several times before I understand what that character's job really was in relationship to the making of a movie. Once I understood the direction it became an easier read, and most insightful.

ALL THE BROKEN PIECES  by John Boyne is a griping novel set in the
present day but takes us back to a dark past when now 91 year-old Gretel comes face to face with her past and that of her father's--a Nazi commandant for Hitler. 

THE BERRY PICKERS by Amanda Peters spans decades of time after 

four-year-old, Ruthie, vanishes while her Mi'kmaq family in Maine is picking blueberries. It is not a mystery but instead focuses on the family and the emotional fallout as the years pass by.  I found myself so caught up in the drama that I have forgotten much of the story except for the ending.  This might be an easier book to read the second time around. 

Because it is Valentine's I am leaping ahead to a book we read last month THE CORRESPONDENT by Virginia Evans received an Eagle vote. I applauded the story because the writing of letters was a way of life when I was growing up.  What Evans has done with character building through letters written back and forth is exceptional.  To read a review of this epistolary novel click on this link: The Correspondent Review











Tuesday, January 21, 2025

Readers in the Rough--Recommended Books for 2025

Books read, reviewed, discussed and enjoyed in the calendar year of 2024.

Voted a PAR=2 points


Our discussion over the HITCHHIKERS GUIDE TO THE GALAXY by Douglas Adams (in January 2024) took most of us "completely out of our comfort zone" of reading and relating to plot. Science Fiction is not a genre that our book club selects.  This book prevailed and, in the discussion, we began to realize the strength of the plot, character development and delight with the change of settings.

 Our eyes were opened as we discovered that one of us deeply enjoyed the story and shared her tales of reading it several decades ago and now reading it again.  We understood the theme "searching for the meaning of life"  but not necessarily the character's approach to answering the question.  It did receive a PAR for its perspective and plot.   


To better explain our "golf terminology and voting" think of a scale of 1-5 with 5 being the best and you would recommend it to any type of reader or a Hole-In-One, and a 1 being a bogey that you may or may not recommend to others to read. 

With that we began our year reading, discussing, and deciding on our one important vote for books.

HOLE-IN-ONE

THE RIDE OF HER LIFE THE TRUE STORY OF A WOMAN, HER HORSE, AND THEIR LAST CHANCE JOURNEY ACROSS AMERICAN by Elizabeth Letts took us on one of the greatest journeys we've ever taken through the power of literature. I cannot imagine how a 200-pound woman could ride across America on horseback from the Atlantic to the Pacific in 1954 without a map. Her fortitude and strength of character never let us down. Her journey provides us with a glimpse of her faith in America and the world in 1954 and how we treated a total stranger on horseback with kindness. 

She well deserved a HOLE-IN-ONE rating for 5 points. 




EAGLE: This is one of the strongest years to have so many excellent books that could have been rated Hole-in-Ones except for a point or one-half a point. 




THE HEAVEN AND EARTH GROCERY STORE by James McBride brings together the strength of a community that bonds, no matter the color of skin, the religious background or the amount of money one has. They all share a common core of caring for our brothers and sisters. Perhaps there is a lesson to be learned for all of us in the century. 




SHELTERWOOD by Lisa Wingate takes us to southeastern Oklahoma during some of the darkest times, when mankind shared no love, no kindness, and cast-off children who learned to survive on their own in the cold darkness of the Washita mountains. This story from the 1900's couldn't be more opposite in the theme than what I like to read. However, a woman and then women begin to take hold of the story and we see how characters, both real and imagined, step up to save the lives of innocent people during the relentless race to own the land that has oil underneath. 

No, I do not like reading stories like this, but I recognize the value they carry for us today. I respect the research, plot and character development to make this a compelling story that I could not put down. 

 

TRUST is a story structured around three very different points of view. This trickster puzzle unfolds like the Japanese phenomenon that describes how different people can have different, contradictory stories about the same event.  This technique called the Rashomon effect is often used to highlight how unreliable eye- witnesses testimony can be.  

It begins with an affluent Manhattan couple who ask people to trust them with their money as Benjamin Rask makes shady deals that keep them affluent during the crash of 29 but plunge their investors into poverty. 

The next two points of view make the reader sit back and think. It is not a quick read nor a compelling plot, but it does challenge the reader to solve the question of who is telling the truth of the story.  


THE WOMEN by Kristen Hannah vividly portrays the war in Vietnam from a woman, Frankie, who in 1965 joins the Army Nurse Corps and ships out to Vietnam. Her gut crushing front line experience overwhelmed her and added to the chaos and destruction dropping her to her knees. Her sheer determination pulls the reader through the war.

It is the story after the war that struck a cord with me, a high school graduate of 1965, who lost friends and classmates to the war, and who saw our boys come home damaged and foully treated by the people they fought for. The women in Frankie life experience the same rejection in their attempt to reintegrate into society. As in real life it is the friendship that rescue and endure these nurses.  

THESE PRECIOUS DAYS essays by Ann Patchett, once again pushed us out of our comfort zone. We each read and reported on at least one of the stories that moved us. Through Patchett's speeches and reflections on life the reader discovers the depth of this author's life and influences her readers. Writing Out Loud--Ann Patchett







BIRDIE VOTES: these books each held something different for the readers to enjoy and grasp. Sunflowers using Vincent Van Gogh's life as a jumping off point; The Library Book, the story of the LA Library fire in 1986, has taken on new meaning with the destructive fires in southern California this winter. The library barely withstood a disastrous fire that reached 2000 degrees consuming four thousand books and damaging even more. It also brought a community  together to save and rebuild a vital institution of their city. 
















Osman's book and then series of The Thursday Murder Club provided us with a high-spirited discussion on the who dunnit level. We fell in love with these senior citizens, Elizabeth, Joyce, Ibrahim, and Ron, who pushed the envelope on the value of the creative and energetic mind of an aging population and all with a sense of humor and perspective. After three of our book club members confessed to having read another two or three of the titles even before we discussed the first one, I found myself ordering all three remaining titles on my Kindle and reading nothing else till I finished them. These mysteries provided a great escape that made me smile and laugh. 


PAR (We set the bar with a par rating.) The Birdie's, Eagles and Hole-in-Ones must be stronger in plot, character development, setting, theme, writing style, point-of-view and/or entertainment level.

THE HITCHHIKERS GUIDE TO THE GALAXY by Adams


THE CLIFF'S EDGE by Charles Todd is a murder mystery to be solved by nurse Bess Crawford. There lies a dark truth behind two once close families as they take sides after a murder is committed.  

We had earlier read No Shred of Evidence, an Ian Rutledge Scotland Yard investigator, and liked it enough to select another book in this mystery series. They are most certainly worthy of a good round of pars. 

Charles Todd's writing reflects the team of Charles and Caroline Todd, a mother-and-son writing team who have created the Inspector Rutledge and nurse, Bess Crawford series. Who is Charles Todd?


In golf and in reading we all can relate to or enjoy a bogey every now and then. That is why we felt we could still give a bogey book one point. This year we didn't read any books that we didn't think worthy of our time. I, however, made up for the bogey's on the golf course. Hitting more bogeys year after year seems to be a theme in my golf game. 

*If you only have time or energy to read one of these books, may I recommend THE RIDE OF HER LIFE. She will not let you down. 

Thursday, October 10, 2024

Readers in the Rough Highlights

 Already this year, 2024, our book club has voted for one book that received a vocal unanimous vote. This book is a memorable ride through life in 1952 on the back of a horse. I couldn’t wait until January to give you this title. It is a must read for every woman young or old.

THE RIDE OF HER LIFE: THE TRUE STORY OF A WOMAN, HER HORSE, AND THEIR LAST-CHANCE JOURNEY ACROSS AMERICA by Elizabeth Letts.

Can you, in 2024, even imagine getting on a horse and traveling from the East coast to the West coast without a map, without a phone, no GPS, no relatives to contact in case of an emergency, and very little money? Then join Annie, Tarzan her brown gelding and her faithful mutt and begin the journey. I assure you that you will not be disappointed.


One book “The Thursday Murder Club”  by Richard Osman, intrigued the majority of us into reading all four published books in that series. For a light enjoyable series of murder mysteries filled with plot twists, character development, a setting in an “old folks home”  and a woman named Joyce who gives her two cents worth on a regular basis, you may decide to read all four books this fall. 

READERS IN THE ROUGH HIGHLIGHTS

A par rating must meet the following criteria: a solid plot showing person against person, person against self, person against society and/or person against nature. Beyond plot development it must show character changes, a theme or take away that we can discuss and understand, a point-of-view and voice that lends itself to telling the story. One underlining element is that it must be a worthy topic for our group. 

We then give the books a numerical rating:

1 bogey—does not meet the criteria but a few read it

2 par—meets the criteria 

3 birdie—meets the criteria for a par and creates a excellent discussion

4 eagle--meets the criteria for a par/birdie and is long remembered perhaps for different reasons, and highly recommended to others.

5 hole-in-one—meets the criteria above and rises to the top of expectations in plot, character development, theme and voice. This book will continue to be highly recommended to others.


2023 Highly rated books

One book received a “Hole-in-One” or 5 points and nearly a standing ovation—


LESSONS IN CHEMISTRY by Bonnie Garmus.


https://www.bonniegarmus.com/lessons-in-chemistry

Five books received overwhelming agreement for an “eagle” or 4 points:

REMARKABLY BRIGHT CREATURES by Shelby Van Pelt

MAD HONEY by Jodi Picoult and Jennifer Finney Boylan

THE MARRIAGE PORTRAIT by Maggie O’Farrell

LADY TAN’S CIRCLE OF WOMEN by Lisa See

TOM LAKE by Ann Patchett

The MAGNIFICIENT LIVES OF MARJORIE MERRIWEATHER POST received the biggest mix of votes : 3 voted for a Par, 3 voted a Birdie, 2 voted an Eagle, and 2 voted it a Hole-in-One. In the end, it received a “birdie” rating.

 

2022 Highly rated books.

No book received the highest rating in 2022. However, we did discuss and try to persuade one and another to vote this book as a hole-in-one. In the end, our votes added up to an “Eagle” rating for--

THE LINCOLN HIGHWAY by Armor Towles

Curiously enough “9” novels received a BIRDIE rating which is still quite a compliment to the authors.  Our readings took us from Africa to the Pink City of Jaipur India; from Nebraska to NYC; Oxford, England, to Iceland; Paris and to Bombay; the Sunset Strip in LA to J.P. Morgan’s vast library in NYC.

These novels received a “birdie” rating:

THE HENNA ARTIST by Alka Joshi

THE NO.1 LADIES’ DETECTIVE AGENCY by Alexander McCall Smith

THE DICTIONARY OF LOST WORDS by Pip Williams

MEET ME IN BOMBAY by Jenny Ashcroft

DAISY JONES AND THE SIX by Taylor Jenkins Reid

THE SECRETS OF THE SPRAKKAR by Eliza Reid

THE PERSONAL LIBRARIAN by Marie Benedict and Victoria Murray

A MOVEABLE FEAST by Ernest Hemingway

THE PARIS WIFE by Paula McLain

 

2021 Highly rated books.


THE FOUR WINDS by Kristin Hannah received a ‘hole-in-one” vote with one person voting it a par because the ending was so very difficult. Sometimes stories of the Dust Bowl and the Great Depression strike too close to our hearts.

The “eagle” ratings went to:

THE ROSE CODE by Kate Quinn

 





2020 Highly rated books.

LILAC GIRLS by Martha Hall Kelly received a “hole-in-one” rating.

Two book received an ‘eagle” rating:

THE TEA GIRL OF HUMMINGBIRD LANE BY Lisa See

THE DUTCH HOUSE by Ann Patchett

 



2019 Highly rated books.

No book received a “hole-in-one” rating.

Three books received an “eagle” rating:

BEFORE WE WERE YOURS by Lisa Wingate

THE ONLY WOMAN IN THE ROOM by Marie Benedict

NEXT YEAR IN HAVANA by Chanel Cleeton

 

2018 Highly rated books



BENEATH A SCARLET SKY by Mark Sullivan











A GENTLEMAN IN MOSCOW by Amor Towles

Two books received an “eagle” rating:

EDUCATED by Tara Westover

KILLERS OF THE FLOWER MOON by David Grann

 






Between 2015—2017 I joined two book clubs and devoured some griping novels, some of which come under the new heading of “literary fiction.”

For more information on these books click here: Intriguing Readings  https://www.blogger.com/blog/post/edit/7852702753078267542/4116389582679811196